Bacteriuria during urinary tract catheterization: suprapubic versus urethral route: a prospective randomized trial. A prospective randomized controlled trial comparing suprapubic with urethral catheterization in rectal surgery. Suprapubic versus transurethral bladder drainage after colposuspension/vaginal repair. Total joint arthroplasty and incidence of postoperative bacteriuria with an indwelling catheter or intermittent catheterization with one-dose antibiotic prophylaxis: a prospective randomized trial. Prospective randomized controlled trial of urethral versus suprapubic catheterization. Urinary tract infections and asymptomatic bacteriuria after vaginal plastic surgery. A comparison of suprapubic and transurethral catheters. Clinical application of the Bardex IC Foley catheter. Effect of a single-use sterile catheter for each void on the frequency of bacteriuria in children with neurogenic bladder on intermittent catheterization for bladder emptying. A comparison of suprapubic and transurethral drainage for postoperative urinary retention in general surgical patients.
In this randomized prospective trial urethral and suprapubic routes were compared in terms of tolerance and infectious potential. Daily bacteriuria determined infectious danger and patients were interrogated on the pain and discomfort induced by their catheter every day. Identical single dose pre-operative antibiotic prophylaxis was routinely applied. Patients (n = 50) were divided into two similar groups (25 suprapubic catheters and 25 urethral catheters). Four patients in the suprapubic group were excluded. All specimen cultured by suprapubic catheter remained sterile. Nine patients with urethral catheterization eventually developed bacteriuria. The difference became significant on the third day of catheterization (p < 0.05) and increased on days 4 and 5 (p < 0.01). Between the two groups, pain and discomfort did not achieve statistical significance. Suprapubic catheterization is preferable to the alternative using the urethral route in terms of improving urine sterility. Bladder drainage is necessary for several days following rectal surgery. Urethral catheterization has long been known to be associated with significant morbidity. Therefore a prospective randomized trial was performed to determine if this morbidity could be decreased by suprapubic catheterization.
                One hundred and thirty-seven patients undergoing rectal surgery were prospectively randomized to either suprapubic or urethral catheterization.
                After exclusions, 108 patients were analysed. Of the 49 patients with suprapubic catheters there was 14% morbidity, and of the 59 patients with urethral catheters there was 32% morbidity. Significant bacteriuria was halved with suprapubic catheterization. Patient acceptability of suprapubic catheterization was high, and there was no increased morbidity in any of the areas studied.
                This study suggests that suprapubic catheterization has advantages over urethral catheterization with decreased bacteriuria, and greater patient acceptability. However, the significance of decreased bacteriuria is not clear and therefore we can only say suprapubic catheter drainage is comparable to urethral catheter drainage. Ninety-two patients with preoperative sterile urine undergoing colposuspension or vaginal repair operation for stress urinary incontinence and/or genital descensus were randomized to either suprapubic or transurethral postoperative catheter drainage. The prevalence of significant bacteriuria on the fifth postoperative day was statistically significantly lower when using suprapubic catheter (20.8%) than with transurethral catheter drainage (45.5%). This applied especially to colposuspension. The rate of postoperatively impaired bladder emptying also tended to be reduced when using suprapubic catheter. At follow-up after one year, postoperative bacteriuria was closely correlated to increased rates of both clinical cystitis and asymptomatic significant bacteriuria. Thus it is recommended to use suprapubic bladder drainage not only after colposuspension but also after vaginal repair in an effort to avoid an increased risk of urinary infections. This study examined the difference in postoperative bacteriuria in total joint arthroplasty after use of either an indwelling catheter or intermittent catheterization. Previous studies showed a preference for an indwelling catheter over intermittent catheterization to resolve postoperative urinary retention in total joint arthroplasty, but these studies generally used 48 hours of antibiotic prophylaxis. Increasing awareness of costs and bacterial resistance to antibiotics have prompted many centers to reduce prophylaxis to only 1 preoperative dose A prospective, randomized, controlled trial was conducted in primary total hip and primary total knee arthroplasty patients. One dose of cefazolin, 1 g, was administered intravenously immediately preoperatively. Five of 13 (38%) men in the indwelling catheter group and 0 of 14 (0%) men in the intermittent catheterization group developed postoperative bacteriuria (P =.016), and 6 of 33 (18%) women in the indwelling catheter group and 3 of 39 (8%) women in the intermittent catheterization group developed postoperative bacteriuria (not significant). A total of 11 (24%) patients in the indwelling catheter group (n = 46) and 3 (6%) patients in the intermittent catheterization group (n = 53) developed postoperative bacteriuria (P =.018). In this setting with 1-dose antibiotic prophylaxis, intermittent catheterization resulted in a lower incidence of postoperative bacteriuria compared with an indwelling catheter. For men, this difference is significant. Sixty-six patients requiring catheterization in the course of general surgical operations were randomly allocated into two groups. Of the 34 patients catheterized urethrally 16 developed urinary tract infections whereas of the 32 suprapubically catheterized patients only 2 developed an infection (P less than 0.001). Five patients required recatheterization after removal of their urethral catheters. There were no major complications associated with the use of suprapubic catheters. We propose that, when catheterization is required during a general surgical procedure, the suprapubic route is to be preferred. In a prospective randomized study comprising 90 women undergoing vaginal plastic surgery, suprapubic and transurethral catheter drainage of the bladder were compared regarding urinary tract infection and asymptomatic bacteriuria. No statistically significant differences were found. The mean duration of catheterization was 4.9 days for suprapubic vs 3.3 days for transurethral catheter patients. Postoperative urinary tract infection was diagnosed in 23.7% of patients with suprapubic and in 27.5% of patients with transurethral catheters. Asymptomatic bacteriuria at catheter removal was found in 21.0% of suprapubic and in 12.5% of transurethral catheter patients. More mechanical complications were seen with SPCs than with TUCs. It is concluded that the two methods involve similar risks of infectious complications but that SPCs have a higher rate of mechanical complications. We performed two randomized prospective studies with the silver-coated Bardex IC catheter in order to evaluate the incidence of bacteriuria during short- and medium-term catheterization after urological procedures.
                During catheterization only consecutive suprapubic urine samples were taken and cultured. After removal of the catheter the patient was allowed one wash-out void, and before the second micturition a suprapubic puncture was performed to collect a culture specimen.
                In the first trial, after radical prostatectomy 18 patients with the Bardex IC catheter were compared to 17 patients with a silicon catheter after the same procedure. There was no significant difference in bacteriuria after 14 days (50.0 vs. 53.3%). In the second part of the study 180 patients were evaluated 101 with latex and 79 with Bardex IC catheters. The median catheterization time was 5 days. The results show a significant delay in the onset of bacteriuria when a silver alloy catheter is used (p < 0.003). On day 5 only 6.3% had bacteriuria in the Bardex IC group versus 11.9% in the latex group.
                We conclude that, after urological procedures, short-term catheterization with the Bardex IC catheter is superior to the classical latex catheter. The frequency of bacteriuria is high in children with neurogenic bladder on intermittent catheterization for bladder emptying. In an effort to decrease bacteriuria, we examined whether the method of catheter care was responsible for the high rate of bacteriuria. For this, the frequency of bacteriuria was examined in the same patient on single-use sterile catheters and on reused clean catheters.
                A prospective, randomized, crossover trial was conducted with 10 patients who were randomized to 4 months of a new, sterile catheter for intermittent catheterization and 4 months of reuse of a clean catheter for intermittent catheterization. Each week, a urine sample was collected and symptoms of infection and medication use were recorded.
                A total of 158 urine samples were collected during 164 patient-weeks on the new catheter method for each void; 115 (73%) were positive for a pathogen. Of the 161 samples collected during 169 patient-weeks on the standard, reuse method for voiding, 123 (76%) were positive (115 [73%] of 158 vs 123 [76%] of 161). Escherichia coli was the most common pathogen detected during both method periods.
                A new, sterile catheter for each void did not decrease the high frequency of bacteriuria in patients with neurogenic bladder on intermittent catheterization. Percutaneous suprapubic bladder drainage, using an indwelling Silastic catheter, was compared with transurethral catheterization for the management of postoperative urinary retention in general surgical patients. In a prospective controlled trail, the overall incidence of postoperative retention was 7%. The urinary infection rate was 70% with transurethral catheterization and 8% with suprapubic drainage. Patients accepted suprapubic damage much more readily than transurethral cateterization and both medical and nursing personnel found the former method easier to manage effectively. Also, the patients' ability to pass urine spontaneously could be assessed without removing the catheter. However, minor mechanical complications were more common with suprapubic drainage. The cost of the two systems is comparable. We conclude that the routine use of suprapubic catheter drainage in the management of postoperative urinary retention significantly reduces the incidence of infection and is the preferred method of treating this common complication.
There was evidence that suprapubic catheters have advantages over indwelling catheters in respect of bacteriuria, recatheterisation and discomfort. The clinical significance of bacteriuria was uncertain, however, and there was no information about possible complications or adverse effects during catheter insertion. 
There was more limited evidence that the use of intermittent catheterisation was also associated with a lower risk of bacteriuria than indwelling urethral catheterisation, but might be more costly. Using intermittent catheterisation postoperatively limits catheterisation to those people who definitely need it.