The treatment of ingrowing toenails. A randomised comparison of wedge excision and phenol cauterisation. The surgical treatment of ingrowing toenails. Approach to ingrowing toenails: the wedge resection/segmental phenolization combination treatment. Segmental phenolization of ingrowing toenails: a randomized controlled study. Ingrowing toenails: studies of segmental chemical ablation. Ingrowing toenails: improving treatment. Randomized, prospective study of nail bed ablation for recurrent ingrowing toenails. Are antibiotics necessary in the treatment of locally infected ingrown toenails? Wound healing and infection in nail matrix phenolization wounds. Does topical medication make a difference?
We treated 249 patients for ingrowing toenails in a prospective randomised study which compared wedge excision with segmental phenol cauterisation. Follow-up of 97% was at a minimum of 14 months. The analgesic requirement was significantly lower after phenol cauterisation (p less than 0.001), and significantly fewer patients needed to miss school or work (p = 0.001). Recurrence of ingrowth was seen in 16% after wedge excision and 9.6% after phenol cauterisation (not significant), but re-operation was significantly less frequent after phenol (p less than 0.01). Phenol cauterisation gives better short-term and long-term results than wedge resection. Two prospective studies of ingrowing toenail management were conducted. In the first, 163 patients (204 ingrowing nail edges) who had not had previous surgery were randomised and treated by total nail avulsion, nail edge excision, or nail edge excision with phenolisation of the germinal matrix; recurrence rates one year postoperatively were 73%, 73% and 9% respectively. In the second study, 63 ingrowing nail edges which had recurred after previous operations underwent nail edge excision and phenolisation. There was a 5% recurrence rate and 5% incidence of dystrophy of the nail one year after operation. One hundred and seventy procedures were performed on one hundred and forty patients with ingrowing toenails. Each patient was randomly allocated to one of three treatment groups. There were 55 wedge resections (WR), 53 segmental phenolizations (SP) and 62 wedge resection/segmental phenolization combination treatments (WR/SP). All patients were followed up for 6 months. The duration and intensity of postoperative pain was assessed and the recurrence rate monitored. Postoperative pain was less in the WR/SP group (9.4 +/- 13.5 h) than in the WR group (30.0 +/- 37.6 h, P less than 0.001). There were seven recurrences in the WR group, four in the SP group, and none in the WR/SP group. The results in the WR/SP group were statistically significant when compared with the WR group (P less than 0.01) and with the SP group (P less than 0.05). We conclude that the WR/SP combination procedure is a superior form of treatment for ingrowing toenails. One hundred and three patients, on whom 107 procedures for ingrowing toenails were performed, were randomly allocated into one of two treatment groups: segmental or angular phenolization and wedge excision. There were 53 wedge excisions and 54 segmental phenolizations. Post-treatment discomfort was assessed on a linear analogue scale of 10 cm. There was no difference between the two groups one week after treatment. Over a mean follow-up period of 14 months a total of 20 nail spikes occurred, 4 in the phenolized group and 16 in the wedge excision group, this being a significant difference at the one per cent level. Recent studies have suggested that segmental ablation is the treatment of choice for patients with ingrowing toenails and that the success rate is 96%. This procedure has been common practice among chiropodists for 20 years, usually using phenol in the United Kingdom, and sodium hydroxide in the United States. However, there has been little critical evaluation of the relative merits of the two chemicals, of the period of chemical application, or of the duration of post-operative pain and healing time. We therefore embarked upon a number of controlled prospective studies to examine these questions. A prospective study of 422 procedures for patients with ingrowing toenails (onychocryptosis) shows that good results are achieved by segmental chemical ablation performed by chiropodists in 91% of cases. The average period of post-operative pain is 3.6 days. Similar results are obtained using either 80% phenol or 10% sodium hydroxide. We believe that segmental chemical ablation by a chiropodist is the treatment of choice for the typical patient with an ingrowing toe nail. Sixty-six patients with ingrowing toenails were randomly assigned to one of two treatment groups and followed up for 16 to 30 months after surgery. In group A 39 nail edges in 32 patients were treated by excision of the nail edge and chemical ablation of germinal matrix edge with 70% aqueous phenol. There were 34 patients in group B, in whom 46 nail edges and germinal matrix edges were surgically excised. In group A recurring symptoms developed in four (10%) nail edges, necessitating further surgery, and asymptomatic spicules developed in seven (18%) nail edges. Two (4%) nails in group B required reoperation and spicules developed in 10 (22%). Both procedures were performed as outpatient surgery, relieved pain and infection, and were acceptable to patients. At an average 2-year follow-up, both procedures yielded comparable results that were superior to those of simple avulsion. A consecutive series of 31 recurrent ingrowing toenails, which had previously undergone at least two surgical procedures, were recruited to this study over a 1-year period. Patients were randomly allocated to one of two treatment groups. Group A underwent nail bed excision whilst group B had nail bed phenolization in addition to excision. Patients were reviewed 2 weeks and 1 year after operation. Seven toes (41%) in group A developed postoperative infection compared with only one (7%) in group B (P less than 0.01). Recurrent nail spicules occurred in ten patients (59%) in group A and six patients (43%) in group B 1 year after operation. High failure rates for ablation of recurrent ingrowing toenails should encourage greater efforts towards adequate treatment at the first presentation. A wide variety of generalists and specialists treat locally infected ingrown toenails, with perhaps the most common treatment regimen including resection of the nail border coupled with oral antibiotics.
                To determine whether oral antibiotic therapy is beneficial as an adjunct to the phenol chemical matrixectomy in the treatment of infected ingrown toenails.
                We prospectively enrolled healthy patients with infected ingrown toenails. Each patient was randomly assigned to 1 of 3 groups that received either 1 week of antibiotics and a chemical matrixectomy simultaneously (group 1), antibiotics for 1 week and then a matrixectomy (group 2), or a matrixectomy alone (group 3).
                Institutional ambulatory outpatient clinic.
                Fifty-four healthy patients with infected ingrown toenails were studied. Patients with immunocompromised states, peripheral vascular disease, or cellulitis proximal to the hallux interphalangeal joint were excluded. Groups were age matched for comparison.
                Mean healing times for groups 1, 2, and 3 were 1.9, 2.3, and 2.0 weeks, respectively. Subjects receiving antibiotics and a simultaneous chemical matrixectomy (group 1) healed significantly sooner than those receiving a 1-week course of antibiotics followed by a matrixectomy (group 2). There was not a significant difference in healing time between those that received a chemical matrixectomy alone (group 3) and those that received a matrixectomy coupled with a course of oral antibiotics (group 1).
                The use of oral antibiotics as an adjunctive therapy in treating ingrown toenails does not play a role in decreasing the healing time or postprocedure morbidity. After nail matrix ablation using phenolization, a medicated wound dressing (10% povidone iodine), an amorphous hydrogel dressing (Intrasite Gel), and a control dressing (paraffin gauze) were evaluated. Forty-two participants, randomly divided into three dressing groups, were evaluated. Healing time did not differ between the 10% povidone iodine (33 days), amorphous hydrogel (33 days), and the control dressing (34 days). For all groups, the clinical infection rate was lower than in previous studies, and there was no clinical difference between groups (one infection in the povidone iodine and control groups; none in the amorphous hydrogel group). However, in the amorphous hydrogel group, other complications, such as hypergranulation, were more likely. This investigation indicated that medicated or hydrogel dressings did not enhance the rate of healing or decrease infection rates.
Surgical interventions are more effective than non-surgical interventions in preventing the recurrence of an ingrowing toenail.
In the studies comparing a surgical intervention to a surgical intervention with the application of phenol, the addition of phenol is probably more effective in preventing recurrence and regrowth of the ingrowing toenail. Because there is only one study in which the surgical interventions in both study arms were equal, more studies have to be done to confirm these outcomes.
Postoperative interventions do not decrease the risk of postoperative infection, postoperative pain, or healing time.