Q:

Is this 'new releases in SF&F' question on topic?

This question has been closed, (not edited) and then reopened, and is now getting close votes again.  One user even voted to both close and reopen it.  Seems like we don't know what to do with this question.  The main thrust of it is:

Where do you guys find out about recently published novels in Science Fiction and Fantasy?
I'm not interested in reviews, news on which writer might write what, which bookstore has closed, conventions etc., just a simple list of everything that is newly available in bookstores.

They're looking for resources that provide thorough listings of Sci-fi & Fantasy book releases.  Is this on topic, or off topic?  Why?

A:

I think the question is fine.
The scope is well-defined, and it doesn't seem likely that there will be so many answers that we'd risk a lot of "me too" answers.  
While there could be several different yet acceptable, answers, I  don't think that's sufficient reason to close it.  
The subject itself is both relevant and of potential interest to a significant number of our members.

A:

This seems like an unanswerable question. Sure, a few good sites could be recommended, but in the end, any number of answers could be equally acceptable. Given that possibility, it seems like it's not really a good question for Stack Exchange.

