model stringclasses 5
values | task_id stringclasses 150
values | source stringclasses 6
values | rollout int64 0 4 | passed bool 2
classes | checks_accuracy float64 0 1 | parsed bool 1
class | output_tokens int64 149 25.1k | completion stringlengths 195 1.3k |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_1 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.857143 | true | 2,628 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "focal_consolidation": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [392, 372, 452, 438]}, "diagnosis": "Right perihilar solitary pulmonary nodule, suspicious for neoplasm; no pneumonia", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression"... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_1 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.857143 | true | 809 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "focal_consolidation": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [392, 378, 448, 438]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule, right mid zone (perihilar); no pneumonia", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Rounded ~4... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_1 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.857143 | true | 791 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "focal_consolidation": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [392, 368, 452, 428]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule right mid zone adjacent to the right hilum; no pneumonia", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impressio... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_1 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.857143 | true | 795 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "focal_consolidation": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [395, 362, 460, 438]}, "diagnosis": "Right perihilar/mid-zone pulmonary nodule, no pneumonia", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Lobulated ~5 cm rounde... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_1 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.857143 | true | 1,057 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "focal_consolidation": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [393, 368, 452, 428]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary right perihilar/mid-zone pulmonary nodule; no pneumonia", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "No consolidat... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_ptx_basal | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.833333 | true | 3,419 | {"findings": {"pneumothorax_present": true, "tracheostomy_present": true, "pneumothorax_side_of_patient": "right", "pneumothorax_box": [245, 170, 515, 560]}, "diagnosis": "Right-sided pneumothorax in a tracheostomised ICU patient", "next_step": "emergency_action", "impression": "Right pneumothorax with apical and later... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_ptx_basal | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.833333 | true | 3,213 | {"findings": {"pneumothorax_present": true, "tracheostomy_present": true, "pneumothorax_side_of_patient": "right", "pneumothorax_box": [235, 200, 335, 585]}, "diagnosis": "Right-sided pneumothorax in a tracheostomised ICU patient; tracheostomy tube appears appropriately sited in the trachea", "next_step": "emergency_ac... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_ptx_basal | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.666667 | true | 1,938 | {"findings": {"pneumothorax_present": true, "tracheostomy_present": true, "pneumothorax_side_of_patient": "left", "pneumothorax_box": [800, 320, 925, 790]}, "diagnosis": "Left pneumothorax with tracheostomy tube in situ", "next_step": "emergency_action", "impression": "Tracheostomy tube in satisfactory midline position... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_ptx_basal | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.833333 | true | 1,989 | {"findings": {"pneumothorax_present": true, "tracheostomy_present": true, "pneumothorax_side_of_patient": "right", "pneumothorax_box": [240, 170, 520, 430]}, "diagnosis": "Right apical pneumothorax in a tracheostomised ICU patient", "next_step": "emergency_action", "impression": "Tracheostomy tube in situ, tip projecte... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_ptx_basal | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.666667 | true | 1,365 | {"findings": {"pneumothorax_present": true, "tracheostomy_present": true, "pneumothorax_side_of_patient": "left", "pneumothorax_box": [830, 330, 960, 720]}, "diagnosis": "Left pneumothorax in a ventilated tracheostomised ICU patient; tracheostomy tube in satisfactory midline tracheal position", "next_step": "emergency_... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_1 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.375 | true | 1,113 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "consolidation_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "abnormal_side_of_patient": "left", "mass_box": [872, 652, 938, 718], "consolidation_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Small rounded nodular opacity in the left lower zone; no pneumonic consolidation, no pneumothorax", "ne... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_1 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.375 | true | 812 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "consolidation_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "abnormal_side_of_patient": "left", "mass_box": [872, 658, 938, 722], "consolidation_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule in the left mid/lower zone, no pneumonic consolidation", "next_step": "urgent... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_1 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.5 | true | 1,635 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "consolidation_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "abnormal_side_of_patient": "left", "mass_box": [860, 650, 940, 725], "consolidation_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Focal rounded opacity in the left lower zone suspicious for a pulmonary nodule/mass; no pneumonic conso... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_1 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.375 | true | 1,140 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "consolidation_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "abnormal_side_of_patient": "left", "mass_box": [870, 655, 930, 715], "consolidation_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule in the left lower zone; no pneumonic consolidation", "next_step": "urgent_rev... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_1 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.125 | true | 3,370 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": false, "consolidation_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "abnormal_side_of_patient": "none", "mass_box": null, "consolidation_box": null}, "diagnosis": "No radiographic evidence of pneumonia; lungs clear, no mass, no pneumothorax", "next_step": "none", "impression": "Cle... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_4 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.2 | true | 2,036 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "No pulmonary nodule; rounded left mid-zone opacity is an external ECG electrode (with wire), not a lung lesion", "next_step": "routine_followup", "impression": "Portable film with multiple lines/leads; ... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_4 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.2 | true | 1,305 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "No pulmonary nodule; round densities are external ECG electrodes and L side marker. Lines/tubes in situ without pneumothorax.", "next_step": "routine_followup", "impression": "Rotated ICU portable film:... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_4 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0 | true | 2,489 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Central venous catheter with tip projecting over the SVC region; no pneumothorax; no pulmonary nodule (round opacities are ECG electrodes)", "next_step": "none", "impression": "Rotated portable AP film:... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_4 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0 | true | 2,673 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Right internal jugular central venous catheter with tip projecting over the SVC; no pneumothorax; no pulmonary nodule (round opacities are ECG electrodes and the L marker)", "next_step": "none", "impres... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_4 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.8 | true | 3,258 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [482, 583, 514, 615]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary right lower zone pulmonary nodule; central venous catheter tip projecting over SVC, no pneumothorax", "next_step": "routine_followup", "impression": "Incidental well-defined nod... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_10 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.714286 | true | 2,542 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [300, 405, 355, 460]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule right mid zone; no pneumothorax", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "No pneumothorax or c... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_10 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.714286 | true | 1,153 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [302, 538, 364, 600]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule right mid/lower zone; no pneumothorax", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "No pneumothora... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_10 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.428571 | true | 1,747 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "No pneumothorax; cardiomegaly with elevated left hemidiaphragm, no acute focal lung lesion", "next_step": "routine_followup", "impression": "... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_10 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.857143 | true | 1,168 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "left", "nodule_box": [612, 462, 690, 540]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule in the left mid zone adjacent to the hilum; no pneumothorax", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impress... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_10 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.857143 | true | 2,476 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "left", "nodule_box": [645, 540, 715, 610]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary left lower zone pulmonary nodule; no pneumothorax; enlarged cardiac silhouette on AP film", "next_step": "urgent_revi... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_13 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.875 | true | 4,222 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [402, 460, 436, 496]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary right perihilar pulmonary nodule, indeterminate; no pneumonia, effusion or pneumo... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_13 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.875 | true | 1,286 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [396, 450, 440, 494]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary right perihilar pulmonary nodule in a 70-year-old with chronic cough - suspicious... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_13 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.875 | true | 2,000 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [398, 460, 442, 504]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary right perihilar pulmonary nodule; round ECG electrode projected over left mid zon... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_13 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.875 | true | 1,638 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [396, 452, 444, 500]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary right perihilar pulmonary nodule; no pneumonia", "next_step": "urgent_review", "i... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_13 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.875 | true | 1,263 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [398, 458, 442, 500]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary right perihilar pulmonary nodule; no consolidation, effusion or pneumothorax", "n... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_14 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.857143 | true | 14,395 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [318, 450, 348, 480]}, "diagnosis": "Small solitary nodule right mid zone; cardiac device generator sited in left lower lateral chest with subcutaneous lead segme... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_14 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.714286 | true | 3,246 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [316, 449, 346, 479]}, "diagnosis": "Subcutaneous ICD system in situ (left lateral chest wall generator, parasternal/sub-xiphoid lead) intact, no fracture or disp... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_14 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.714286 | true | 11,000 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [318, 450, 344, 476]}, "diagnosis": "Left lateral chest wall device generator with discontinuous lead segments (right paramediastinal curvilinear segment and left... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_14 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.714286 | true | 6,130 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [316, 451, 346, 481]}, "diagnosis": "Left lateral chest wall subcutaneous ICD generator with subcutaneous/parasternal lead in situ, no lead fracture or pneumothor... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_14 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.714286 | true | 4,513 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [318, 451, 343, 476]}, "diagnosis": "Subcutaneous ICD in situ with intact-appearing lead; incidental small well-defined round focal lesion in the right mid zone a... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_21 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.375 | true | 895 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Normal chest radiograph; no evidence of pneumonia", "next_step": "none", "impression": "Clear lungs with n... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_21 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.375 | true | 4,392 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "No radiographic evidence of pneumonia; clear lungs, no nodule, effusion or pneumothorax; heart size at upp... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_21 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.875 | true | 1,968 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [345, 478, 402, 535]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule, right perihilar/mid zone; no pneumonia", "next_step": "urgent_r... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_21 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,313 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "left", "nodule_box": [595, 405, 665, 470]}, "diagnosis": "Left perihilar pulmonary nodule without evidence of pneumonia", "next_step": "urgent_review... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_21 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.375 | true | 1,427 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Normal frontal chest radiograph; no radiographic evidence of pneumonia", "next_step": "none", "impression"... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_23 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.75 | true | 7,854 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "right", "nodule_box": [195, 650, 255, 705]}, "diagnosis": "Incidental solitary pulmonary nodule right lower zone; no acute traumatic injury (no rib f... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_23 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.375 | true | 6,018 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "No acute traumatic thoracic injury; right internal jugular tunnelled (dialysis-type) central venous cathet... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_23 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.875 | true | 2,978 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "left", "nodule_box": [610, 580, 680, 650]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule projected over the left mid zone/left cardiac border; bilateral t... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_23 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.875 | true | 4,802 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "left", "nodule_box": [615, 365, 670, 420]}, "diagnosis": "Left mid-zone pulmonary nodule; indwelling cardiac device leads/catheter, no pneumothorax, ... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_23 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.875 | true | 8,260 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "left", "nodule_box": [758, 602, 812, 656]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary left lower zone pulmonary nodule lateral to the left heart border; cardiac device ... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_24 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.428571 | true | 2,548 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Marked elevation of the right hemidiaphragm with smooth dome-shaped homogeneous right basal opacity - subpulmonic effusion versus diaphragmat... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_24 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.857143 | true | 2,348 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "left", "nodule_box": [628, 370, 690, 430]}, "diagnosis": "Left perihilar pulmonary nodule; elevated right hemidiaphragm (possible subpulmonic effusion vs hepatomegaly/phrenic palsy); n... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_24 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.571429 | true | 2,501 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Marked elevation of the right hemidiaphragm with large subdiaphragmatic soft-tissue density - subpulmonic effusion vs hepatomegaly/eventratio... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_24 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.428571 | true | 3,107 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "Elevated right hemidiaphragm with homogeneous subdiaphragmatic density - subpulmonic effusion vs eventration/hepatomegaly; no nodule, consoli... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_nodule_24 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.285714 | true | 3,356 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodule_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "focal_consolidation": false, "nodule_side_of_patient": "none", "nodule_box": null}, "diagnosis": "No pleural effusion; no acute cardiopulmonary abnormality", "next_step": "none", "impression": "Clear lungs with sharp costophrenic angles an... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_5 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.833333 | true | 962 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "right_basal_opacity_present": true, "mass_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_box": [120, 470, 520, 900]}, "diagnosis": "Large well-circumscribed mass occupying the right mid-to-lower hemithorax, obscuring the right hemidiaphragm and right heart border; no meniscus of free pleura... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_5 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.833333 | true | 939 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "right_basal_opacity_present": true, "mass_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_box": [130, 470, 570, 890]}, "diagnosis": "Large well-defined homogeneous right lower hemithorax mass with convex superior margin obscuring the right hemidiaphragm and right heart border; no meniscus of... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_5 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.833333 | true | 1,085 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "right_basal_opacity_present": true, "mass_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_box": [110, 480, 480, 900]}, "diagnosis": "Large well-circumscribed mass occupying the right lower hemithorax, obscuring the right hemidiaphragm and right heart border", "next_step": "urgent_review", "i... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_5 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.833333 | true | 1,072 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "right_basal_opacity_present": true, "mass_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_box": [130, 500, 530, 890]}, "diagnosis": "Large dense homogeneous mass-like opacity occupying the right lower hemithorax with convex upper margin, obscuring the right hemidiaphragm and costophrenic ang... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_5 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.833333 | true | 1,255 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "right_basal_opacity_present": true, "mass_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_box": [160, 470, 530, 880]}, "diagnosis": "Large well-defined homogeneous opacity in the right lower hemithorax with convex upper margin obscuring the right hemidiaphragm, most consistent with a large r... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_6 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.857143 | true | 6,438 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "right_basal_opacity_present": true, "mass_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_box": [360, 570, 500, 730]}, "diagnosis": "Malpositioned left-sided central venous catheter running down the left mediastinal border to the diaphragm (persistent left SVC ... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_6 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.857143 | true | 2,094 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "right_basal_opacity_present": true, "mass_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_box": [360, 590, 510, 770]}, "diagnosis": "Malpositioned left-sided central venous catheter (aberrant course along left mediastinal/heart border to diaphragm, tip not in S... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_6 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.857143 | true | 4,820 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "right_basal_opacity_present": true, "mass_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_box": [385, 600, 520, 755]}, "diagnosis": "Right perihilar/lower zone mass-like opacity with adjacent right basal consolidation and elevated right hemidiaphragm; left-side... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_6 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.857143 | true | 4,278 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "right_basal_opacity_present": true, "mass_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_box": [385, 590, 530, 760]}, "diagnosis": "Right perihilar/lower-zone mass with right basal opacity and elevated right hemidiaphragm (likely lower lobe collapse/effusion);... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_6 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.857143 | true | 3,232 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "right_basal_opacity_present": true, "mass_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_box": [370, 590, 520, 740]}, "diagnosis": "Left-sided central catheter with aberrant course descending along the left paramediastinal border to the diaphragm level (suspec... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_7 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 0 | false | 0.777778 | true | 1,716 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": true, "effusion_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_side_of_patient": "left", "mass_box": [530, 315, 615, 400], "effusion_box": [95, 600, 380, 790]}, "diagnosis": "Right pleural effusion with a rounded left upper zone/aort... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_7 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 1 | false | 0.777778 | true | 1,266 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": true, "effusion_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_side_of_patient": "left", "mass_box": [525, 318, 615, 405], "effusion_box": [85, 610, 375, 830]}, "diagnosis": "Right pleural effusion with a left upper zone focal mass a... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_7 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 2 | false | 0.777778 | true | 1,406 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": true, "effusion_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_side_of_patient": "left", "mass_box": [525, 315, 618, 405], "effusion_box": [85, 620, 420, 800]}, "diagnosis": "Left upper zone/perihilar rounded mass with right basal pl... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_7 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 3 | false | 0.777778 | true | 1,525 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": true, "effusion_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_side_of_patient": "left", "mass_box": [525, 318, 618, 400], "effusion_box": [88, 610, 350, 810]}, "diagnosis": "Right pleural effusion with a rounded left perihilar/aorto... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_nih_search_7 | NIH ChestX-ray14 | 4 | false | 0.777778 | true | 1,902 | {"findings": {"focal_mass_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "pleural_effusion_present": true, "effusion_side_of_patient": "right", "mass_side_of_patient": "left", "mass_box": [528, 318, 615, 405], "effusion_box": [85, 610, 340, 800]}, "diagnosis": "Right pleural effusion with a rounded left upper zone / pa... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_nodule_2 | ChestX-Det | 0 | false | 0.75 | true | 2,319 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_box": [392, 322, 448, 372]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule, right perihilar/mid zone", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Rounded ~4-5 cm... approx 3 cm opacity projected over the right hilum/mid zone, not clearly vascular; nipple markers pres... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_nodule_2 | ChestX-Det | 1 | false | 0.75 | true | 2,895 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_box": [665, 405, 730, 470]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule, left perihilar/medial mid zone", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Well-defined rounded opacity (~3 cm) adjacent to the left hilum consistent with a pulmonary nodule; cardiomediastin... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_nodule_2 | ChestX-Det | 2 | false | 0.75 | true | 2,314 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_box": [393, 318, 442, 366]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule, right mid zone adjacent to the hilum", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Not a normal film: ~3-4 cm rounded opacity lateral to the right hilum suspicious for a pulmonary nodule; othe... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_nodule_2 | ChestX-Det | 3 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,506 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_box": [385, 320, 448, 385]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule, right mid zone (perihilar), otherwise clear lungs, normal heart size and mediastinum", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Not normal - rounded ~5 cm-range perihilar/right mid zone nod... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_nodule_2 | ChestX-Det | 4 | false | 0.75 | true | 2,995 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_box": [660, 395, 750, 480]}, "diagnosis": "Left perihilar pulmonary nodule, indeterminate", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Rounded nodular opacity projected over the left hilum on an otherwise unremarkable pre-operative film; not normal - recommend ... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_multi_1 | ChestX-Det | 0 | false | 0.5 | true | 1,578 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[424, 344, 450, 370], [430, 385, 458, 412], [406, 505, 434, 533], [316, 498, 344, 526]]}, "diagnosis": "Multiple small dense calcified nodules right perihilar and lower zone, consistent with healed granulomatous disease", "next_step": "routine_followup",... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_multi_1 | ChestX-Det | 1 | false | 0.5 | true | 1,378 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[419, 346, 443, 370], [431, 385, 455, 409], [404, 510, 428, 534], [314, 497, 338, 521]]}, "diagnosis": "Multiple small densely calcified nodules in the right mid/lower lung and right hilar region, consistent with old healed granulomatous disease (calcifi... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_multi_1 | ChestX-Det | 2 | false | 0.5 | true | 1,731 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[412, 506, 440, 534], [418, 346, 448, 372]]}, "diagnosis": "Small dense (likely calcified) pulmonary nodules in the right lung, most consistent with old granulomas; low lung volumes with elevated hemidiaphragms", "next_step": "routine_followup", "impress... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_multi_1 | ChestX-Det | 3 | false | 0.5 | true | 1,441 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[427, 351, 449, 373], [434, 387, 457, 409], [421, 412, 444, 435], [405, 508, 428, 531]]}, "diagnosis": "Multiple small dense (calcified-appearing) nodules in the right perihilar and right lower zone, consistent with old healed granulomatous disease; lung... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_multi_1 | ChestX-Det | 4 | false | 0.5 | true | 1,807 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[420, 342, 446, 368], [428, 383, 454, 409], [416, 418, 442, 444], [312, 498, 340, 526], [408, 508, 434, 534]]}, "diagnosis": "Multiple small dense (calcified-appearing) nodules in the right perihilar region and right lower zone, most consistent with calc... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_ptx_1 | ChestX-Det | 0 | false | 0.75 | true | 2,665 | {"findings": {"pneumothorax_present": true, "pneumothorax_box": [760, 80, 915, 500]}, "diagnosis": "Left apical/lateral pneumothorax without mediastinal shift", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Left-sided pneumothorax with visceral pleural edge at the upper lateral hemithorax; no tension features; no displa... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_ptx_1 | ChestX-Det | 1 | false | 0.75 | true | 2,224 | {"findings": {"pneumothorax_present": true, "pneumothorax_box": [680, 100, 910, 770]}, "diagnosis": "Left pneumothorax with hyperlucent left hemithorax and visible lateral visceral pleural edge; left chest port in situ; no displaced rib fracture identified", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Left-sided pneum... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_ptx_1 | ChestX-Det | 2 | false | 0.75 | true | 2,186 | {"findings": {"pneumothorax_present": true, "pneumothorax_box": [585, 45, 865, 430]}, "diagnosis": "Left apical/upper zone pneumothorax with hyperlucent left upper lung and visible pleural edge; small catheter/device overlying left upper chest; no displaced rib fracture confidently identified", "next_step": "urgent_rev... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_ptx_1 | ChestX-Det | 3 | false | 0.75 | true | 5,221 | {"findings": {"pneumothorax_present": true, "pneumothorax_box": [120, 200, 300, 880]}, "diagnosis": "Right-sided pneumothorax (lateral/basal lucency with depressed right hemidiaphragm), no definite rib fracture", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Hyperlucent, expanded right hemithorax with lateral/basal pneu... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_ptx_1 | ChestX-Det | 4 | false | 0 | true | 2,225 | {"findings": {"pneumothorax_present": false, "pneumothorax_box": null}, "diagnosis": "No pneumothorax; no displaced rib fracture identified", "next_step": "none", "impression": "Lung markings extend to the chest wall bilaterally with no visceral pleural line, mediastinal shift or deep sulcus; no displaced rib fracture ... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_multi_2 | ChestX-Det | 0 | false | 0.428571 | true | 1,903 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "focal_consolidation_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "nodule_boxes": [[660, 575, 735, 655]], "consolidation_boxes": []}, "diagnosis": "Rounded left perihilar opacity suspicious for pulmonary nodule/hilar mass; no consolidation or pneumothorax; borderline ... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_multi_2 | ChestX-Det | 1 | false | 0.714286 | true | 1,697 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "focal_consolidation_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "nodule_boxes": [[650, 565, 745, 690]], "consolidation_boxes": [[300, 740, 445, 905]]}, "diagnosis": "Left perihilar mass-like opacity with right lower zone patchy consolidation; no pneumothorax", "next_... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_multi_2 | ChestX-Det | 2 | false | 0.571429 | true | 1,573 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": false, "focal_consolidation_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "nodule_boxes": [], "consolidation_boxes": [[270, 640, 440, 900]]}, "diagnosis": "Right lower zone patchy consolidation with cardiomegaly; no nodule or pneumothorax", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impr... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_multi_2 | ChestX-Det | 3 | false | 0.714286 | true | 2,115 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "focal_consolidation_present": true, "pneumothorax_present": false, "nodule_boxes": [[640, 555, 725, 700]], "consolidation_boxes": [[300, 740, 445, 910]]}, "diagnosis": "Left hilar mass-like opacity with patchy right lower zone airspace consolidation; no pneumothorax", "... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_chestdet_multi_2 | ChestX-Det | 4 | false | 0.428571 | true | 1,417 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "focal_consolidation_present": false, "pneumothorax_present": false, "nodule_boxes": [[650, 565, 745, 660]], "consolidation_boxes": []}, "diagnosis": "Left perihilar pulmonary nodule/mass, suspicious for neoplasm; no consolidation or pneumothorax", "next_step": "urgent_r... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_1 | VinDr-CXR | 0 | false | 0 | true | 1,352 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": false, "nodule_boxes": []}, "diagnosis": "No focal pulmonary nodule or consolidation identified; clear lungs", "next_step": "none", "impression": "Frontal chest radiograph without discrete pulmonary nodule, consolidation, effusion or pneumothorax; cardiomediastinal contours wi... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_1 | VinDr-CXR | 1 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,684 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[705, 610, 795, 700]]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary rounded pulmonary nodule in the left lower zone; no consolidation, effusion or pneumothorax", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Left lower zone pulmonary nodule in a patient with chronic cough - i... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_1 | VinDr-CXR | 2 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,970 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[375, 480, 465, 580]]}, "diagnosis": "Right perihilar rounded opacity suspicious for pulmonary nodule/mass; no consolidation or effusion", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Rounded right perihilar/mid-zone opacity in a patient with 2-month cou... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_1 | VinDr-CXR | 3 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,255 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[305, 600, 385, 680], [655, 415, 720, 480]]}, "diagnosis": "Pulmonary nodules - right lower zone perihilar and left perihilar rounded opacities; no consolidation to explain cough as infection", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Rounded pulmona... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_1 | VinDr-CXR | 4 | false | 0.75 | true | 952 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[300, 400, 430, 530], [655, 420, 705, 470]]}, "diagnosis": "Right perihilar mass-like opacity with a smaller left parahilar nodular density; neoplasm or granulomatous infection (TB) to be excluded", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Right mid-... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_2 | VinDr-CXR | 0 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,331 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[212, 672, 250, 708]]}, "diagnosis": "Small solitary pulmonary nodule in the right lower zone; otherwise clear lungs, normal heart size, no effusion", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Not normal - small right lower zone pulmonary nodule, inde... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_2 | VinDr-CXR | 1 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,489 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[325, 512, 388, 572]]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule right mid zone, perihilar", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Rounded opacity projected over the right perihilar mid zone consistent with a pulmonary nodule; otherwise clear lungs... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_2 | VinDr-CXR | 2 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,563 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[128, 702, 174, 744]]}, "diagnosis": "Small well-defined nodular opacity right lower zone, likely calcified granuloma; otherwise clear lungs, normal heart and mediastinum", "next_step": "routine_followup", "impression": "Small solitary nodule right lower... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_2 | VinDr-CXR | 3 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,018 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[202, 674, 230, 702], [802, 698, 830, 726]]}, "diagnosis": "Small pulmonary nodules, right and left lower zones; otherwise clear lungs and normal cardiomediastinal contours", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Not normal - two small rounded pul... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_2 | VinDr-CXR | 4 | false | 0.25 | true | 740 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": false, "nodule_boxes": []}, "diagnosis": "Normal chest radiograph", "next_step": "none", "impression": "Clear lungs, normal cardiomediastinal contours, sharp costophrenic angles; no pulmonary nodule, consolidation, effusion or pneumothorax."} |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_3 | VinDr-CXR | 0 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,224 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[598, 498, 658, 558], [678, 315, 720, 357]]}, "diagnosis": "Left lung pulmonary nodules - dominant left mid-zone perihilar nodule with a smaller left upper-zone nodular opacity", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Well-defined rounded nodule in... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_3 | VinDr-CXR | 1 | false | 0.75 | true | 1,177 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[660, 285, 725, 350], [580, 495, 645, 555]]}, "diagnosis": "Pulmonary nodules - left upper zone nodule overlying anterior left 2nd rib and rounded left perihilar opacity", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Rounded nodular opacity in the left u... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_3 | VinDr-CXR | 2 | false | 0.75 | true | 835 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[655, 300, 715, 358]]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule, left upper zone", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Rotated frontal film; small rounded nodular opacity in the left upper zone below the clavicle projected over the anterior ribs... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_3 | VinDr-CXR | 3 | false | 0.75 | true | 800 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[680, 300, 730, 350]]}, "diagnosis": "Solitary pulmonary nodule, left upper zone", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Rounded soft-tissue density in the left upper zone projected over the posterior ribs, consistent with a pulmonary nodule; comp... |
anthropic/claude-fable-5.1 | read_vindr_multi_3 | VinDr-CXR | 4 | false | 0.75 | true | 956 | {"findings": {"pulmonary_nodules_present": true, "nodule_boxes": [[672, 318, 722, 372], [522, 392, 602, 478]]}, "diagnosis": "Left upper zone pulmonary nodule with adjacent left paramediastinal/aortopulmonary rounded opacity - suspicious for neoplasm", "next_step": "urgent_review", "impression": "Rounded nodular opacit... |
RadRead β public results
Rollout-level results for RadRead, a benchmark of frontier models reading 150 radiographs. Every row is one graded model read: 5 saved rollouts per study per model, scored by a deterministic grader (no judge model).
A read passes only when every required checklist finding, lesion box (the grader's
IoU / centre / containment test), lexical diagnosis check and action-set membership
check match the reference rubric. No partial credit inside a study; checks_accuracy
is the share of individual gold checks passed. Diagnosis matching is not disease-level
validation. urgent_review is accepted on 148/150 keys, so urgency discrimination
remains weak. Deterministic membership is not clinical adjudication, and a rubric
failure is not necessarily a clinical error.
Scores are re-derived from the saved transcripts against the current gold, so a gold correction
changes passed here without a re-run. Traces with the grader's per-check verdicts:
https://dylantirandaz.com/radread-leaderboard/traces/
Leaderboard
| Model | Lab | pass@1 (%) | 95% study-bootstrap CI | 5/5 cases | pass@5 (%) | Never solved |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-6 Astra | OpenAI | 25.9 | 19.7β32.3 | 24 | 36.0 | 96 |
| Claude Opus 5 | Anthropic | 22.1 | 16.7β27.9 | 15 | 35.3 | 97 |
| Claude Fable 5.1 | Anthropic | 19.7 | 14.9β24.7 | 6 | 37.3 | 94 |
| Gemini 3.8 Flash | 15.6 | 10.9β20.5 | 9 | 26.0 | 111 | |
| GPT-5.6 Sol | OpenAI | 13.6 | 8.9β18.8 | 14 | 21.3 | 118 |
Rows are ordered by pass@1 point estimate, not proven model superiority. pass@1 is the mean single-attempt pass rate across studies; 5/5 is the count of cases passing every saved attempt. pass@5 is secondary, not a reliability measure.
95% intervals use a paired percentile study bootstrap: 10,000 shared resamples of 150 studies, seed 42. All attempts within a study stay together; attempts are not independent resampling units. Descriptive intervals conditional on this outcome-selected challenge cohort and its saved responses, not an independent holdout or population/clinical validation. Studies, not individual attempts, are resampled. Intervals do not account for cohort selection, gold-label uncertainty, or future responses; pairwise intervals are not adjusted for multiple comparisons.
All paired pass@1 differences and their intervals are in leaderboard.json and the
expandable table on the results page. Differences are in fractions in JSON and
percentage points on the page; pairwise intervals are not multiplicity-adjusted.
Small-n source breakdowns are exploratory, not evidence of source-level differences.
pass@k uses 1 - C(n-c, k) / C(n, k) over 5 saved rollouts.
The first 5 provider-successful attempts are retained in pinned run/file
order. Model failures count; provider errors do not. Historical extra attempts remain archived.
Protocol
- Sampling: temperature 0, 65,536 max tokens, xhigh (OpenAI and Claude); high (Gemini)
- Inference: Prime Intellect Inference (api.pinference.ai)
- Images: 1024 x 1024 px, one radiograph per study, sent on the image channel
Current release and lineage
public150-pass5-audit1 corrects public150-pass5: the same 150 studies and 3,750
saved responses (750 per model), regraded without new inference or cohort changes.
NIH14 retains the original source right-lateral box and removes a contradictory
left-hilar alternative. ChestDet26 adds an omitted source calcification as an optional
reference; both existing foci remain required. The laterality audit is also corrected.
These source-backed corrections are not clinical validation and do not fix the
remaining diagnosis, urgency or outcome-selection limitations.
The original release used 3,725 cached reads plus 25 new fifth attempts. Its immutable snapshots remain available: GitHub benchmark and HF results.
The parent 164-study cohort was selected using all five models' saved outcomes to keep
each model's pass@4 below 35%. Of those studies, 145 already had five cached attempts
for every model. Five of the remaining 19 were sampled with seed 42 before generating
their new fifth attempts, one per model. The 150-case selection was frozen in
results/pass5_150.selection.json before those new outcomes. This correction retains
that selection and the original prompts, images and responses; references and the
laterality audit are corrected as described above.
This release inherits the parent's outcome selection: it is an outcome-selected challenge subset, not an independent holdout or evidence of general model performance deterioration. The scores above describe the exported cohort, not an unselected population.
Fields
| field | meaning |
|---|---|
model |
provider/model id as served |
task_id |
study identifier in the benchmark |
source |
upstream image source |
rollout |
rollout index, 0-based |
passed |
the read satisfied every gold check |
checks_accuracy |
share of individual gold checks passed |
parsed |
the reply contained a parseable JSON read |
output_tokens |
completion tokens for the read |
completion |
the model's raw reply |
Not included
Radiograph pixels and the gold annotations stay out of this dataset. Images come from ChestX-Det, NIH ChestX-ray14, VinDr-CXR, GRAZPEDWRI-DX, FracAtlas and the RSNA Pneumonia Detection Challenge under their own licences; obtain them from those sources.
- Downloads last month
- 67